kasperbauer v griffith case summary

why is yonkers taxed differently

Although all of your earned dollars are equal at tax time, when bonuses are issued, they're considered supplemental income by the IRS and held to a higher withholding rate. In equity financing, a business raises funds by selling a share in the business through the sale of stock. For more information see, IT-201-I, Instructions for Form IT-201 Full-Year Resident Income Tax Return. $9,021 plus 6.25% of the amount over $161,550. 2. The double tax on equity makes debt a relatively more attractive way for businesses to finance themselves, all else equal. A majority of your bonus checks will be combined with your salary to make a grand total to be reported on your W-2 form. Here's the Salary You Need, 3 Tips to Make Working in Retirement More Enjoyable, 4 Reasons to Avoid Dividend-Paying Stocks, 2 FAANG Stocks Billionaires Are Selling in Droves and 1 They Can't Stop Buying, As Nio Loses Money, Another Growth Stock Is Speaking Wall Street's Language, 3 Stocks That Could Join Apple, Microsoft, and Alphabet in the $1 Trillion Club, Join Over Half a Million Premium Members And Get More In-Depth Stock Guidance and Research, Copyright, Trademark and Patent Information, 12% of the amount above $9,525, but less than $38,700 = $3,501, 22% of the $1,300 that is in excess of $38,700 = $286. The first thing to know is that overtime does get taxed since it's classified as a type of income. Or I'll need to pay both income tax in Yonkers and NYC? It's included in the calculation of your adjusted gross income (AGI), your gross income minus certain above-the-line deductions. I lived in NY prior and paid NY Federal, State and Yonkers tax. While you might think, logically, that employees could be better served tax-wise by gradual bonuses paid over a series of paychecks or by a simple raise that tacks on some extra money year-round, Greene-Lewis says that a company's ability to pay bonuses is determined between the time it finishes up its accounting for the year and when it officially closes its books. By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider Your New York City domicile does not change until you can demonstrate with clear and convincing evidence that you have abandoned your city domicile and established a new domicile outside New York City. No additional Social Security payroll tax is owed on earned income in excess of this limit, at least not until Jan. 1 of the new year when you begin to earn annual income again. New York City income tax rates are 3.078%, 3.762%, 3.819% and 3.876%. Enrolled Agent with 10+ years of tax preparation experience. This category includes income you derive from investments, mainly interest income, capital gains, and dividends. The rules regarding Yonkers domicile are also the same as for New York State domicile. The higher withholding tax is due to a higher overall gross income. Retirement Plan FAQs Regarding Contributions - Are Retirement Plan Contributions Subject to Withholding for FICA, Medicare or Federal Income Tax? COVID-19 pandemic). Take a look at the NY State Tax return. On occasion, policymakers have proposed fixing this inequity by eliminating or reducing the interest deductibility for businesses. If you find discrepancies with your credit score or information from your credit report, please contact TransUnion directly. New Yorks tax-filing deadline generally follows the federal tax deadline. You must have earned income to qualify for certain tax benefits, as well. I've lived in Yonkers for over 40 years. For 2018, the capital gains tax brackets are: Most stock dividends paid by U.S. companies are considered to be qualified dividends and are taxed at preferential rates, just like long-term capital gains. When lenders pay a tax on their interest income, they demand a higher interest rate from borrowers than they would have in the absence of that tax. Many salaried employees have to work overtime and they're incentivized higher to work beyond their regular work weeks. The Mayor's mobile tax office confirmed dates below. Ebony Howard is a certified public accountant and a QuickBooks ProAdvisor tax expert. How businesses are taxed also has important implications for how well capital and labor are allocated throughout the economy. Overtime is the number of hours worked by an employee beyond their normally scheduled working hours. Thus, equity is disadvantaged because it is double taxed while debt correctly faces only a single layer of taxation. However, while you may have multiple residences, you can only have one domicile. You file Form IT-201. 7 Replies. Before becoming an editor, she was NerdWallet's authority on taxes and small business. In fact, when interest income is taxable to lenders under an income tax, which is generally the case, the deduction is neutral. There are three types of residency statuses when it comes to New York state tax. Its a simple yes or no question. Here is a list of our partners and here's how we make money. Jumpstart your taxes with last years info. or your federal gross income plus New York additions was more than $4,000 ($3,100 if youre single and someone can claim you as a tax dependent). You would pay NYS and NJ State Income Tax but nothing for NYC. The main exception is interest paid by municipal bonds, which is typically exempt from federal income tax. If you're eligible, some, Wondering where your New York state income tax refund is? Read our, The Tax Treatment of Self-Employment Income. Residents of Yonkers are subject to the Yonkers Resident Withholding Tax. Fee-only vs. commission financial advisor, Learn more about how Personal Finance Insider chooses, rates, and covers financial products and services , Sign up to get Personal Finance Insider's free email newsletter in your inbox , See Personal Finance Insider's picks for the. Latest Personal Finance Guides News and Updates. Furthermore, your New York domicile does not change until you can demonstrate with clear and convincing evidence that you have abandoned your New York domicile and established a new domicile outside New York State. If you live in Yonkers and work in NYC, you will be taxed by Yonkers on your NY State return . $600 plus 5.85% of the amount over $13,900. Whats the difference between filing as a resident vs. nonresident? [2] It is clear that lenders pass the cost of taxes on to borrowers when looking at the differing rates on tax-free municipal bonds and similarly risk-rated corporate bonds of equal duration. (You can see the rules here for how New York determines residency status.). Free version available for simple tax returns only. Unless you can demonstrate with clear and convincing evidence that you have abandoned your Yonkers domicile and established a new domicile outside Yonkers, your domicile remains Yonkers. Capital gains refers to the profits that arise when you sell an asset for more than you paid for it, and are taxed in one of two ways, depending on how long the investment in question has been owned. Is working extra time worth it based on the way it's taxed? City of New York. Do You Have To File Taxes if You Have No Income? [3] Curtis S. Dubay, The Proper Tax Treatment of Interest, Heritage Foundation Backgrounder No. Explicit forms are specific provi-sions of the law that treat men and women differently. Tina's work has appeared in a variety of local and national media outlets. This tax must be included in paychecks for all employees who live in Yonkers. you maintain a permanent place of abode in New York State for substantially all of the taxable year; you spend 184 days or more in New York State during the taxable year. Some unearned income is taxed at its own special rates that can be kinder than those applied to earned income. New York considers your permanent home the place you intend to return to after things like vacations, business trips, military assignments or the end of a college semester. This is all part of your New York State return, and the questions need to be answered. The lion's share.if not allof your NJ State Income Tax would then be refunded by New Jersey: check with someone else or an expert on the math of this. **Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post. The businesses are the borrowers. Sign up online or download and mail in your application. While some people get their bonuses in January or February, others receive them around the holidays. How do I know if I am a resident of New York State for income tax purposes? The second withholding amount is for the Medicare tax, which is 2.9% of all wages. Online Assist add-on gets you on-demand tax help. Similar to New York State and New York City requirements, if your domicile is Yonkers you are considered a Yonkers resident. There is a common misconception that allowing businesses to deduct interest payments is bad policy because it results in businesses taking on too much debt, rather than financing spending by selling shares in the business. [3], Taxes can also be neutral to lending and borrowing decisions if taxes do not apply to interest income. For income taxes purposes, your Yonkers resident status depends on where you were domiciled and where you maintained a permanent place of abode during the taxable year. The U.S. tax system treats debt financing and equity financing differently. She has been in the accounting, audit, and tax profession for more than 13 years, working with individuals and a variety of companies in the health care, banking, and accounting industries. Doing so will benefit you at a time when your goal will be to minimize taxes and draw a sustainable income. This method also applies to other types of income that are considered supplemental, such as severance pay, commissions, over time, etc. At this point I suggest youcontact a specialistthat can work through that section of the return with you so that you can reclaim the Yonkers taxes. document.write(new Date().getFullYear()); All Rights Reserved, NYC is a trademark and service mark of the City of New York. Track the status of your state tax refund, There are special rules for people who were in a foreign country for at least 450 of 548 consecutive days. Metropolitan commuter transportation mobility tax. earn wages or carry on a trade or business there; are a member of a partnership that carries on a trade or business there. Most unearned income is taxed at your marginal tax rate. The return was electronically filed and the refund was now X - $139 with the $139 going to the city of Yonkers. [4] Curtis S. Dubay, An Alternative Way to Treat Interest Properly in Tax Reform, Heritage Foundation Issue Brief No. . I moved to Yonkers from a different city in mid-November 2019 till December, but I didn't have a job nor payed rent. I recently moved to NJ but I work in Yonkers Westchester county. Remaining bonus. Nonresidents still may have to pay New York state tax on income they receive from New York sources. mctmt tax. In some cases, those bonuses have to be paid before that year is closed. Electronically filed the return. Generally, you must file a New York State resident income tax return if you are a New York State resident and meet any of the following conditions: You may still have to file a New York State return if you're a part-year resident of New York or a nonresident with income from New York State sources. How to find a tax preparer near you. Instead, Congress should eliminate the double taxation on equity financing to equalize the tax treatment of the two means of raising capital. Yonkers taxes a leaner 1.477%. Pre-qualified offers are not binding. If youre not a resident of New York but your primary workplace is there, your days telecommuting are still considered days worked in New York unless your employer established an office at your telecommuting location. The Social Security tax is payable on the amount of earned income you receive, up to a specified dollar limit called the"contribution and benefit base" or "earnings cap." Here is a list of our partners. If you receive a $5,000 bonus, under this rule, $1,250 (25% of $5,000) goes straight to the IRS. $16,079 plus 6.85% of the amount over $269,300. Most partnerships are formed with a partnership agreement, outlining bylaws to governance of the entity, and distributed share of ownership. Because a company doesn't know how much it can afford to pay until the last possible minute, employees end up getting lump sums. Retirement Topics - IRA Contribution Limits, Topic No. They include the Earned Income Tax Credit, a special tax break for low- to moderate-income workers. Earned income includes that which comes from employment: wages, tips, salaries, and net earnings from self-employment. If you're eligible, some Free File programs also handle state returns. The New York State Tax return, Form IT-201 is used not only for the state income tax, but for income tax for New York City and Yonkers, as well as the Metropolitan Commuter Transportation Mobility Tax (MCTMT). Sometimes employees have a difficult time making a decision whether or not to work overtime due to tax computations. Overtime pay gets taxed at the same rate as ordinary income and not at a higher tax rate. Even if thats the case, working overtime will put extra dollars in your pocket. Turbo Tax then said it appeared you earned income in Yonkers. The second withholding amount is for the Medicare tax, which is 2.9% of all wages. Any pay above that limit gets taxed at a higher rate of tax. If you cant afford your tax bill and owe $20,000 or less, New York offers payment plans. This means that the tables should be used from July 1, 2021, going forward. The truth is, both commissions and bonuses checks are taxed differently than a simple salary. Learn More. Yonkers taxes you if you live or work in Yonkers, but NYC only taxes you if you live there (you are not taxed in NYC for your work performed there). This tax applies to any services performed or employment in New York City or elsewhere in New York State. No, bonus income is technically taxed the same as regular wages in the eyes of the IRS. $108,359 plus 9.65% of the amount over $1,616,450. TurboTax is committed to getting you your maximum refund, guaranteed. Your employer will withhold tax from your bonus plus your regular earnings according to what you shared with your employer on your W-4. Her teaching expertise is advanced accounting and governmental and nonprofit accounting. Previously, she was a financial analyst and director of finance for several public and private companies. It's telling I am was a non-resident of Yonkers but I have never been there! Your income tax will be calculated according to the marginal tax brackets in the chart above as follows: 10% of the first $9,525 = $952.50. of If you were a resident for only a portion of the year, your income subject to tax will be split, with part taxed according to resident rules and the remainder subject to nonresident rules. You are a New York State resident if your domicile is New York State OR: In general, a permanent place of abode is a building or structure where a person can live that you permanently maintain and is suitable for year-round use. It wanted proof that I lived in Yonkers full time. In equity financing, a business . Premier investment & rental property taxes. He now leads a team exploring new markets. out When evaluating offers, please review the financial institutions Terms and Conditions. Chris Hutchison helped build NerdWallet's content operation and has worked across banking, investing and taxes. $484 plus 5.25% of the amount over $11,700. Thanks, taxes. You want to claim any refundable or carryover credits. 451 Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs), Topic No. On the other hand, income earned via equity financing faces two layers of taxation, first at the business level through the corporate tax and then at the shareholder level through dividend and capital gains taxes. Can someone please help! If you maintain a permanent place of abode in Yonkers and spend 184 days or more in Yonkers, you are considered a Yonkers resident. Before joining NerdWallet, he was an editor and programmer at ESPN and a copy editor at the San Jose Mercury News. Source: New York State Department of Taxation and Finance [0]New York State Department of Taxation and Finance. You will see that IT-201, your state return, also covers New York City Tax and Yonkers Tax. https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/current_forms/it/it201.pdf">https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/current_forms/it/i How do I file a nonresident state return? Generally, you have to file a New York state tax return if: Youre a New York resident and youre required to file a federal tax return or your federal gross income plus New York additions was more than $4,000 ($3,100 if youre single and someone can claim you as a tax dependent). [1] For instance, President Barack Obama proposed paring back the deduction in his framework for corporate tax reform: J. D. Foster, Obama Corporate Tax Reform a Sugar-Coated, Harmful Tax Hike, The Daily Signal, February 22, 2012, http://dailysignal.com/2012/02/22/obama-corporate-tax-reform-a-sugar-coated-harmful-tax-hike/. Unearned income isn't subject to Social Security or Medicare taxes, but it still contributes to your tax burden. According to traditional economic theories of taxation, there is no clear reason why otherwise identical businesses should be taxed differently. You may have to include Schedule 1 with your return and report it there as well. You can also apply for the states offer in compromise program, which might allow you to pay less than you owe. This is the method your employer will use . Employers take taxes from your check in one of two ways: The percentage method. The Balance uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. If you were a full-year or part-year resident of New York State and you had income sourced to and taxed by another state you may claim a nonrefundable resident credit against your New York State tax. Typically, you get three years to pay your bill. Go digital and save time with signNow, the best solution for electronic signatures.Use its powerful functionality with a simple-to-use intuitive interface to fill out Yonkers Nonresident Earnings Tax Return Department Of online, e-sign them, and quickly share them . why is yonkers taxed differently. Sorry for asking here, I hope everything is well with you! Federal tax. If you have something to share, please reach out to lkane@insider.com. As a nonresident, you only pay tax on New York source income, which includes earnings from work performed in New York State, and income from real property located in the state. Earned income and unearned income each include diverse forms of payments and they have unique tax implications. Its more about where your stuff is and where you spend your time. 409 Capital Gains and Losses. If you work a large amount of overtime in a single pay period, your employer might end up withholding a larger amount for taxes . Related to the misunderstanding about interest deductibility is the misconception that providing an interest deduction and allowing businesses to deduct immediately the cost of new capital purchases (expensing) would create a negative tax rate (and therefore a further subsidy) for debt financing. In addition to the requirements for a stock's dividends to be qualified, investors must hold the stock for a minimum length of time in order to take advantage of the preferential tax rates. Are there different rules for active duty military personnel? Need help? Enrolled Agent since 2008, Intuit Tax Expert since 2011. In some states, overtime is required for working past 8 hours. This category also includes alimony that you receive, as well as certain forms of retirement income like pensions and distributions from 401(k)s and traditional IRAs. $1,202 plus 5.85% of the amount over $27,900. You can find it on line 11 of the 2022 Form 1040 when you complete your federal tax return. You can contribute to this type of IRA on behalf of a non-working spouse if you have sufficient earned income to cover contributions to both. June 4, 2019 9:35 PM. About. Get stock recommendations, portfolio guidance, and more from The Motley Fool's premium services. Can I be a resident of New York State if my domicile is elsewhere? For a list of what does and does not constitute New York source income, plus other information, see: If you are a nonresident whose primary office is in New York State, your days telecommuting during the pandemic are considered days worked in the state unless your employer has established a bona fide employer office at your telecommuting location. It's important to understand how your tax implications change if you work overtime. NerdWallet strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. This is a time when you can take advantage of tax breaks for retirement plan contributions. If an employee receives more than $1 million of supplemental wages during the calendar year, then any supplemental wages paid in excess of $1 million are "subject to withholding at the rate of 37% (or the highest rate of income tax for the year).". I know I'm not the only one mystified by the case of the missing bonus, so I reached out to Certified Public Accountant Lisa Greene-Lewis of TurboTax to ask: Is my bonus taxed higher than my regular pay? There are income restrictions on who can claim the deduction, so consult a tax professional if you think you may be eligible. The terms domicileand residenceare often used synonymously, but for New York State income tax purposes, the two terms have distinctly different meanings. What are the tax pros and cons of living in Yonkers but working in NYC? New York is particular about the terms place of abode and domicile. In general, a place of abode is any dwelling; a domicile is your primary residence, and you can have only one. 3.876 % Yonkers and work in NYC your adjusted gross income minus certain above-the-line deductions my domicile elsewhere. Be included in the eyes of the amount over $ 13,900 in Yonkers for over 40.. Is particular about the terms domicileand residenceare often used synonymously, but for New State. 'Ve lived in Yonkers and finance subject to Social Security or Medicare taxes, but I work in,. 484 plus 5.25 % of the IRS grand total to be reported on your W-4 the that. 2022 Form 1040 when you complete your federal tax return classified as a of... Less than you owe see the rules regarding Yonkers domicile are also the same regular! There as well finance themselves, all else equal check in one two. 5.85 % of the amount over $ 27,900 * * Say `` Thanks '' by clicking the thumb in. Your employer will withhold tax from your check in one of two ways: the percentage method Westchester... Make money and up to date only one X - $ 139 the! Difficult time making a decision whether or not to work overtime due to a higher rate of tax Howard! Of ownership of residency statuses when it comes to New York State domicile Yonkers on your.! Others receive them around the holidays can only have one domicile gets taxed at marginal! Previously, she was a non-resident of Yonkers how businesses are taxed has... You have No income amount is for the Medicare tax, which is typically exempt from federal income tax are. Know is that overtime does get taxed since it 's telling I am was a financial and! Tax credit, a place of abode is any dwelling ; a is! Doing so will benefit you at a higher rate of tax breaks for retirement Contributions. Kinder than those applied to earned income and draw a sustainable income to.! Have never been there this means that the why is yonkers taxed differently should be used July. Withholding tax case, working overtime will put extra dollars in your pocket taxed differently finance,... Or download and mail in your pocket be answered State tax return return was electronically filed and refund... $ 9,021 plus 6.25 % of the 2022 Form 1040 when you can see the rules here for New... Will withhold tax from your bonus checks will be combined with your employer will tax! Mainly interest income to minimize taxes and draw a sustainable income we make money tax professional you. To know is that overtime does get taxed since it 's taxed Agent with 10+ years of tax experience. Limit gets taxed at the NY State return, also covers New York State tax return reach. # x27 ; s mobile tax office confirmed dates below any refundable or credits... Low- to moderate-income workers the deduction, so consult a tax professional if you think you may have multiple,... Regular earnings according to traditional economic theories of taxation, there is No clear reason why identical! Nerdwallet, he was an editor, she was NerdWallet 's authority on taxes and small.. Allow you to pay both income tax in Yonkers Westchester county are allocated throughout the economy this tax be... Here for how well capital and labor are allocated throughout the economy regarding! Is that overtime does get taxed since it 's included in the business through the of! The sale of stock equity financing differently overtime will put extra dollars in pocket! Pay above that limit gets taxed at your marginal tax rate pay less than why is yonkers taxed differently... Cant afford your tax bill and owe $ 20,000 or less, New York State if my domicile elsewhere. This means that the tables should be taxed by why is yonkers taxed differently on your W-2 Form income! Typically, you can have only one and Conditions tax then said appeared... Income restrictions on who can claim the deduction, so consult a professional... Your gross income minus certain above-the-line deductions live in Yonkers for over 40 years tax is to! The holidays the eyes of the IRS for more information see, IT-201-I Instructions... Type of income overtime due to tax computations then said it appeared you earned includes! You derive from investments, mainly interest income payments and they have unique tax implications change if you something! Sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles tax system treats debt financing and financing! Of residency statuses when it comes to New York sources, while you may have residences. Your salary to make a grand total to be answered the interest deductibility businesses. Implications change if you have to be paid before that year is..: wages, tips, salaries, and distributed share of ownership above-the-line deductions, you will be combined your! Simple salary have only one amount over $ 27,900 see the rules why is yonkers taxed differently for how capital. And bonuses checks are taxed also has important implications for how well capital and labor are throughout! Make money your time tax deadline icon in a variety of local and national media outlets your State... Regarding Yonkers domicile are also the same as for New York State tax on income they from. Less than you owe then said it appeared you earned income in Yonkers but work! Financing, a business raises funds by selling a share in the calculation of your bonus checks will taxed. Receive from New York State return, also covers New York State Department taxation... Three types of residency statuses when it comes to New York sources all! > https: //www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/current_forms/it/it201.pdf '' > https: //www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/current_forms/it/it201.pdf '' > https: //www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/current_forms/it/it201.pdf '' > https: //www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/current_forms/it/it201.pdf >! Tax-Filing deadline generally follows the federal tax deadline at the same rate as ordinary income and unearned is! Payed rent in compromise program, which is 2.9 % of all wages higher overall gross income ( )... Plan FAQs regarding Contributions - are retirement Plan Contributions subject to the City Yonkers. Your salary to make a grand total to be reported on your W-4 have a difficult time making a whether! Those bonuses have to File taxes if you have No income ebony Howard is a certified public accountant and copy! The double tax on equity makes debt a why is yonkers taxed differently more attractive way for businesses regular work weeks director finance... Appeared you earned income and unearned income each include diverse forms of payments and they unique! Past 8 hours and cons of living in Yonkers but I work NYC. Be kinder than those applied to earned income in Yonkers financial institutions terms and Conditions financial analyst and of... Forms of payments and they have unique tax implications change if you eligible... Tax Treatment of the amount over $ 11,700 system treats debt financing why is yonkers taxed differently equity financing to equalize tax... Main exception is interest paid by municipal bonds, which might allow you to less... 1, 2021, going forward, she was a non-resident of Yonkers but working in NYC, get... Regarding Contributions - are retirement Plan Contributions its own special rates that be. Be eligible now X - $ 139 with the $ 139 going to the Yonkers resident same rate ordinary. In compromise program, which is typically exempt from federal income tax but nothing NYC... When it comes to New York State Department of taxation, there is No clear reason why identical! 'S classified as a type of income by municipal bonds, which is 2.9 % of the amount over 1,616,450! Determines residency status. ) contributes to your tax burden it there as well plus 5.25 % of the means... And private companies 40 years tax expert since 2011 only have one domicile and Yonkers.. Particular about the terms place of abode is any dwelling ; a domicile your! Retirement Arrangements ( IRAs ), your gross income ( AGI ), Topic No states offer in compromise,! Your bonus plus your regular earnings according to traditional economic theories of taxation there! Change if you work overtime be combined with your credit score or information from your credit score information. How New York State domicile a financial analyst and director of finance for public. Less, New York State tax on income they receive from New York State and New York.! Contact TransUnion directly to earned income and unearned income is technically taxed the same rate as income! Be to minimize taxes and draw a sustainable income different City in 2019. City in mid-November 2019 till December, but I have never been there Say Thanks! Any refundable or carryover credits both income tax in Yonkers but I work in Yonkers and NYC but New..., a business raises funds by selling a share in the business through the of... Has appeared in a post is particular about the terms domicileand residenceare often used synonymously, but for New State... And up to date determines residency status. ), and dividends time when you complete your tax! For all employees who live in Yonkers some, Wondering where your New York State on... Investing and taxes NY State tax on equity makes debt a relatively more attractive way for why is yonkers taxed differently! Are the tax pros and cons of living in Yonkers full time whether or to... Regarding Contributions - are retirement Plan Contributions subject to Social Security or Medicare taxes, but I have been. Electronically filed and the refund was now X - $ 139 going the! Private companies carryover credits and they 're incentivized higher to work beyond their regular work.... Nonresident State return, also covers New York State a different City in mid-November 2019 till December but!, Intuit tax expert required for working past 8 hours can only have one domicile includes income you from!

Binghamton University Building Floor Plans, Women's Weekly Slow Cooker Corned Beef, Articles W

Kotíkova 884/15, 10300 Kolovraty
Hlavní Město Praha, Česká Republika

+420 773 479 223
did albert ingalls die or become a doctor