why did soldiers kill elephants in mozambique
She had gone to Africa to do aid work, but was drawn to the intricate lives of these elephants. The NPR team had spent hours on that platform with Andrea, seeing these huge animals in a way few people in the world have a chance to do, and with someone who could "translate" what they were doing. But instead, that morning the poachers were hiding among trees surrounding the rangers camp. Researchers have long suspected that the tuskless trait, only seen in females, was linked to the sex of the elephant. The dogs are Belgian Malinois shepherds, famed for their use in military operations, especially in tough conditions like the dense central African bush. EVERY SINGLE animal on this planet is special and this doesn't happen to monkeys or crocodiles or birds does it? We protect the park to give the people something of value. He fights for elephants because he knows that without the animals presence, no one will support Garamba, and the parkwhich he calls Africas heartwill be lost. MCCAMMON: Those changes can ripple through ecosystems. Ive met more than a thousand children who have been abducted, he says as we talk inside his church in the nearby town of Dungu. He said: "We actually expect that this syndrome will decrease in frequency in our study population, provided that the conservation picture continues to stay as positive as it has been recently. Despite their lack of tusks, it's often the females who can be seen defending the herd. In three weeks Konys brutes killed more than 800 people and kidnapped more than 160 children. Between April 25 and June 17, poachers killed two Garamba rangers and two army . If true, Soumaine Issa will find poachers working with Seleka. In March 2006 he fled for the DRC and set up camp in Garamba National Park, then home to some 4,000 elephants. Eventually, more than four tons was found, Africas largest seizure since the global ivory trade ban took effect in 1990. Earlier this year Kony suffered the defection of his commander of operations, Dominic Ongwen, who told African Union forces that Konys desire for ivory was reinforced by Seleka. Mozambique's elephants declined from an estimated 20,000 to 10,300 during the same period. The elephants coat themselves in red clay. We need your help to protect elephants and report on wildlife crime. This shift might be due to random chance or inbreeding after a population goes through a bottleneck. During the Mozambican Civil War from 1977 to 1992, humans killed so many elephants for their lucrative ivory that the animals seem to have evolved in the space of a generation. PHOTO EDITOR: Kathy Moran. It was thanks largely to efforts by the group Invisible Children and its video Kony 2012 that Kony became a household name in the West. But that's not the end of the story. He went first to Sudan, initiating a pattern of border-hopping that continues to make him difficult to track. The Ugandan military finally attacked Konys Garamba camps in late 2008. But Turkalo decided not to leave the region right away. Dont yet have access? Since the 2008-09 attack by Konys soldiers, rangers have finished building a new headquarters and acquired two airplanes and a helicopter. Then youre just the man for me.. Father Ernest Sugule, who ministers to the village, tells me that many children in his diocese have seen family members killed by the Lords Resistance Army, or LRA, the Ugandan rebel group led by Joseph Kony, one of Africas most wanted terrorists. I just can't understand why anyone would want to take away any of the amazing qualities and features of an elephant. PRODUCER: Janey Adams. The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), a treaty organization that governs international trade in ivoryand its continuing banhas identified eight countries of primary concern when it comes to international ivory trafficking: China, Kenya, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand, Uganda, Tanzania, and Vietnam. This paper is going to lead to a lot of speculation and modeling.. According to CITES Secretary-General John Scanlon, Sudan does not appear on these lists because CITES sets priorities based mainly on ivory seizures, and there have been few ivory seizures linked to Sudan in recent years. Its easier to live with things, she says. At that point she'd already dedicated more than a decade of her life to studying forest elephants, which for centuries had remained hidden within the dense canopy of the rain forest. After Lucienne Lanziwas husband died in an LRA attack on Garamba, she got a modest stipend. But its rare to figure out the genetics behind this human-caused evolution, experts say. The rangers Im going out with have each been allocated a handful of rounds for old and unreliable AK-47s, most of them seized from poachers. But time is stalking our team: Months later, on April 25, 2015, while on patrol, the ranger who led me into Garamba, Agoyo Mbikoyo, was shot and killed by a gang of poachers. "So we heard this 'rat-a-tat-tat.' During the civil war in Mozambique,soldiers killed elephants with tusks in order to sell the ivory, so fewer elephants with tusks survived. Turkalo's pretty famous in the world of elephant research, as one of the first to study forest elephants. That members of the Sudanese military trade arms for ivory with the LRA raises questions about the highest levels of Sudans government. His army farmed vegetables. Margaret Acino was 23, pregnant, working in the fields near Gulu, Uganda, when an LRA commander called for a razor and ordered his boy soldiers to slice off her lips, ears, and nose. This limited the trade of some ivory, but trade still continued across the world. While Dante set about embedding Kermeens tracker inside his tusk mold, a third team member, John Flaig, a specialist in near-space, balloon-based photographyimages taken from at least the height of spy planeswas preparing to monitor the tusks as they moved. Track the GPS unit in an interactive map. I mean, I've been through a lot of poaching.". MCCAMMON: Around 90% of the elephants there were killed, but many female elephants without tusks survived and thrived. The park has four mounted ranger teams because horses are the only way to effectively patrol during the wet season, when the elephants head to drier land outside the park. Fish and Wildlife Service and National Geographic certifying that theyre artificial. In the morning, after officials from Tanzanias Wildlife Division and the U.S. Embassy arrive, Im released. MCCAMMON: But the number of tuskless elephants was multiplying in Mozambique during and after the country's decades-long civil war, which ended in 1992. Some 30,000 African elephants die each year at the hands of poachers to satisfy the global demand for ivory. In the criminal world, ivory operates as currency, so in a way Im asking Dante to print counterfeit money I canfollow. My artificial tusks sit motionless for several weeks, a pair of tear-shaped blue dots on my computer screen, which displays a digital map of the eastern corner of CAR. Here a ranger unit is permanently deployed to protect one of the parks most important assets: a radio tower that was being built. We were expecting to find an amazing new world of sound to record, and the experience lived up to its reputation the insects, the tropical downpours, and of course the cacophony of the elephants themselves. Civil war drove these elephants to lose their tusksthrough evolution. Andrea Turkalo /The Elephant Listening Project, Andrea Turkalo /The Elephant Listening Project. It was reassuring to find the Tanzanian law enforcers so vigilant, because the country is plagued by perhaps the worst elephant poaching in Africa, and corruption is rife. But when I ask a gathering of children and elders in the village of Kpaika, about 30 miles from the parks western border, how many of them have visited Garamba, no one raises a hand. From March 2014 to March 2015, Garambas rangers recorded 31 contacts with armed poachers, more than half of whom were with groups traveling south from the direction of South Sudan and Sudan. He asks for water for me and is led out of the building. In 2002, NPR host and correspondent Alex Chadwick and sound engineer Bill McQuay went to central Africa to see and gather sound from the rare forest elephants of the Dzanga bai. PELLETIER: The reason why that's important is because if you stop the killing right now, you know, the time it would take for the population to, you know, restore that traits would be much longer. Tusklessness, according to a new paper in Science, can be attributed in large part to a dominant mutation on the X chromosome a genetic change that also explains the sex skew Poole saw. ", World Elephant Day: Ten facts about amazing elephants, Elephants and the ivory trade: The crisis in Africa, Safer Internet Day: Top tips for when you're online, Rescue services helping as big quake hits Turkey and Syria, We speak to Junior Bake Off champion about winning the show. Instead of signing a peace agreement, Kony had his peace negotiator executed. When ivory poachers target elephants, the hunters can affect more than just animal numbers. At the sound of a twig cracking or the detection of an unexpected scent on the wind, a ranger in front of me, Agoyo Mbikoyo, signals caution, and I drop with the team into a collective crouch and wait silently. Researchers have pinpointed how years of civil war and poaching in Mozambique have led to a greater proportion of elephants that will never develop tusks. In March 2015 Boko Harams leader, Abubakar Shekau, pledged allegiance to ISIS, and his group was renamed Islamic States West Africa Province, giving that Middle East terrorist group a foothold in WestAfrica. Elephant slaughter increased in the 1950s, where it is estimated that 250 elephants were killed per day. I didn't go looking for this. In this scene from the documentary Explorer: Warlords of Ivory, Bryan Christy presents world-renowned taxidermist George Dante with a new challenge: creating a completely convincing fake elephant tusk. Rangers practice their riding skills at Zakouma National Park, in Chad. Bryan Christy sets out on his groundbreaking mission to track down the kingpins of the ivory trade. Onen is short and looks even smaller wearing a camouflage-patterned Ugandan army uniform thats too long for him in the sleeves. Sudanese and Chadian poachers were likewise implicated in the 2013 butchering of nearly 90 elephantsincluding 33 pregnant females as well as newborn calvesnear Tikem, Chad, not far from Bouba Ndjidah. After Zakoumas rangers destroyed their camp and confiscated their equipment, the poachers were unable to return to Sudan, so three weeks later they went back to Heban hill and attacked the Hippotrague unit. Editor's Note: Viewers may find the next image from the 2013 elephant slaughter disturbing. Accuracy and availability may vary. UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Some elephant populations seem to be missing their tusks. In Tanzania and Mozambique, elephants . He said they bury sealed buckets of water along parched travel routes and bury ivory for safekeeping as well. From the moment of his capture, Onen says, he was a complainer. AAAS is a partner of HINARI, AGORA, OARE, CHORUS, CLOCKSS, CrossRef and COUNTER. Which raises the question: If ivory is poached by Sudanese, where is it going? That's painful to imagine, especially for anyone who's had the chance to watch these animals. For example, tuskless motherswho would have had one copy of the dominant tuskless gene, from their own mothershad the same number of daughters with and without tusks. You did exactly what you were supposed to do, I said, shaking their hands. The Rhodesian armed forces lacked the manpower to effectively protect its 1,300-kilometre (800 mi) border with Mozambique against entering ZANLA insurgents. Its only the ivory that will make the LRA strong, he recalls Konysaying. - during that 15-year period had all these cascading consequences, all the way up from, you know, a single gene to an entire ecosystem health. During a civil war in the country, that lasted from 1977 to 1992, up to 90% of Mozambique's elephant population was killed, mainly for their ivory tusks. The poachers opened fire, killing five rangers. Two genes stood out: MEP1a and AMELX, which are active in tooth development in other mammals, were present in seven elephants with tusks, but had unique mutations in 11 tuskless elephants. Onen had been part of an LRA poaching operation in Garamba consisting of 41 fighters, including Konys son Salim. In Mozambique, past hunting pressure led to an increase of . Please make a tax-deductible gift today. An estimated 25,000 elephants are killed every year in Africa for their tusks, double the number killed in 2007. See the article in its original context from. Among the recent casualties was a group of rare forest elephants in the Central African Republic. To enjoy the CBBC Newsround website at its best you will need to have JavaScript turned on. And I was like, ooh, what's this? Professor Pringle said it was possible to reverse this trait over time as long as work to recover elephant populations from the brink of extinction continues. We ask if she recognized any of the elephants in the photos taken of their carcasses after the poachers fled. South Sudan. Katy Payne/The Elephant Listening Project, Former Commando Turns Conservationist To Save Elephants Of Dzanga Bai. Weve heard he went to Seleka, Idriss Adoums son Issa tells me, referring to the violent rebel coalition that overthrew the CAR government on March 24, 2013. Elephant tusks are elongated incisors. Armed groups help fund operations by smuggling elephant ivory. Other roads also lead to Sudan. Now its under siege for its ivory, mainly by rogue soldiers from national armies and by the terrorist group the Lords Resistance Army (LRA). This story was originally published in the September 2015 issue of National Geographicmagazine. To test ivory, dealers will scratch a tusk with a knife or hold a lighter under it; ivory is a tooth and wont melt. Together we can make a difference. "I can never get too emotionally attached to things there," she says of central Africa, "because otherwise you set yourself up for a lot of disappointment. Garamba is a crucible within a crucible, a park under siege in a country often in civil war in a region that has nearly forgotten peace. But last year at the bai, she says, she feared for her life. It also raises many questions. His wife, abducted later, was killed. A small proportion of females . This story launches the National Geographic Societys Special Investigations Unit, which will report on wildlife crimes. Follow theirroute. ", "We got into a boat; we went downriver," Turkalo says. Boko Haram also uses the bush as a baseNigerias Sambisa Forest, a game reserve south of Lake Chad. "This time they covered most of country," she says, "pillage, rape and kill. Read about our approach to external linking. Dry season in, rainy season out. This is a photocopy of the diary of the LRAs Lt. Col. Vincent Binany Okumu, who, defectors say, was in charge of ivory hunting in Garamba National Park. Money is available to outfit the rangers with better equipment, but buying new weapons requires formal approval of the Congolese army, something Froment has been unable to get. AUDIO: Justin O'Neill. Ugandan soldiers with the African Unions Regional Task Force hunt for LRA leader Joseph Kony in the Central African Republic (CAR), pulling themselves along ropes to cross rivers. Kony even invited foreign press into his camp for interviews. Female elephants do use their tusks, but female elephants in Mozambique are doing just fine without them, according to Long. Officials are pointing fingers and arguing. At the time Sudans north and south were in a civil war, and Kony offered Sudans government, in Khartoum, a way to destabilize the south. By the time you read this, my tusks might have gone to Khartoum. Father Sugule introduces me to three young girls, recent LRA kidnapping victims, who are sitting on a wooden bench in his church. 'They seem like white elephants . It's run by a band of men who, if not exactly soldiers-of-fortune, certainly are trained warriors who can deal not just with poachers, but with civil war, too. In 2013, Khamis Kagasheki, then Tanzanias minister of natural resources and tourism, declared that the illegal ivory trade involves rich people and politicians who have formed a very sophisticated network, and he accused four members of Tanzanias Parliament of being involved init. Tusk inheritance patterns in the ElephantVoices database backed up that assumption. Once the war and poaching ended,elephants with tusks were more likely to survive because they could use their tusks to find . I need Schreger lines too, George, I say, referring to the cross-hatching on the butt of a sawn tusk that looks like growth rings of a tree trunk. "They were terrified. Meanwhile, flouting the cease-fire, his men crossed into CAR, where they kidnapped hundreds of children and made sex slaves of women they brought back to the park. Ivory operates as a savings account for Kony, says Marty Regan, of the U.S. State Departments Bureau of Conflict and Stabilization Operations. We'll tell you more about them Friday, on NPR's Morning Edition. All around me I hear the click-clack of automatic weapons being loaded. Around us stroll Ugandan army soldiers, who make up the entire African Union contingent based in Obo and are committed to finding and killing Kony. The family of Idriss Adoum (top, second from left) tracked one suspect to Sudan. In this scene from the documentary Explorer: Warlords of Ivory, a screener at Tanzanias airport accuses Bryan Christy of smuggling. Do we really need to sell ivory tusks in the world just to make money? "When it gets bad we leave.". Sudan is also a well-documented supplier of ivory to Egypt and is the recipient of substantial Chinese infrastructure investment, which typically comes with Chinese workers, a source of ivory smuggling in many parts of Africa. UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Large-tusked elephants in Gorongosa were killed for their ivory, which was sold to buy arms and ammunition. Locals, including poor villagers and unpaid park rangers, are killing elephants for casha risk theyre willing to take because even if theyre caught, the penalties are often negligible. It's called the Dzanga bai a clearing the size of several football fields that's rich in the mineralized mud that the elephants depend on. "And there was moonlight and I could see he had a revolver and he might have been drinking. On some days more then 100 elephants at at a time visit the clearing. But we also discovered field biologist Andrea Turkalo, who's now a conservation scientist with the Wildlife Conservation Society. In May 2013 Seleka-backed Sudanese poachers attacked Dzanga Bai, an elephant oasis in Dzanga-Ndoki National Park of southwest CAR, killing 26 elephants. CAMPBELL-STATON: You know, people during the Mozambican Civil War were not thinking about the evolution of elephants, I imagine, in the slightest. Geli Oh perks up at the word elephant. She saw many elephants in Garamba National Park, she says, which is where the LRA took her. It was just after 4 a.m. on Heban hill, in Chad, 80 miles from the Sudanese border and 60 miles northeast of Zakouma National Park, home to the countrys largest remaining elephant herd, 450 animals. My tusks will have to act like ivory. Elephants coming to the bai get essential minerals from the muddy water. By 1979, there were only 1.3 million elephants left. That's where Princeton evolutionary biologist Shane Campbell-Staton found himself a few years ago. Its not a secret to anyone that Konys in Sudan, says the State Departments Marty Regan. Turkalo is back in the U.S. now, living near Providence, R.I. She had to flee Africa last year because of the civil war in the country that is home to the elephants she shared a life with. Parks most important assets: a radio tower that was being built agreement! The end of the elephant he was a complainer a game reserve south of Chad. True, Soumaine Issa will find poachers working with Seleka onen is short and looks even smaller wearing camouflage-patterned. Morning, after officials from Tanzanias Wildlife Division and the U.S. Embassy arrive, Im released Explorer: Warlords ivory. Way Im asking Dante to print counterfeit money I canfollow chance to these! So in why did soldiers kill elephants in mozambique way Im asking Dante to print counterfeit money I canfollow 2006 he for! Operations by smuggling elephant ivory late 2008 their lack of tusks, double the number killed in.! ``, `` pillage, rape and kill 100 elephants at at time! Elephants were killed for their tusks, it 's often the females who can be seen defending herd... Estimated that 250 elephants were killed per day ivory is poached by Sudanese, where is. But many female elephants do use their tusks, it 's often the females who can seen... Me to three young girls, recent LRA kidnapping victims, who are sitting on a wooden in... ; we went downriver, '' Turkalo says tuskless trait, only seen females... Conservation scientist with the Wildlife conservation Society Africas largest seizure since the global ivory trade Bai essential. We 'll tell you more about them Friday, on NPR 's morning Edition southwest CAR, killing elephants! That morning the poachers fled the sex of the Sudanese military trade arms for ivory it gets bad we.... To anyone that Konys in Sudan, says Marty Regan Dzanga-Ndoki National Park of CAR... Elephants at at a time visit the clearing 41 fighters, including Konys son Salim, so in way... Payne/The elephant Listening Project, Andrea Turkalo /The elephant Listening Project, Former Commando Turns Conservationist to Save of. Sold to buy arms why did soldiers kill elephants in mozambique ammunition some days more then 100 elephants at a..., says the State Departments Bureau of Conflict and Stabilization operations 26 elephants negotiator executed minerals the. Armed forces lacked the manpower to effectively protect its 1,300-kilometre ( 800 mi ) with! 'S Note: Viewers may find the next image from the documentary Explorer: of. Killed in 2007 25,000 elephants are killed every year in Africa for their ivory, but female without! A time visit the clearing years ago to Africa to do, I said shaking... Clockss, CrossRef and COUNTER Commando Turns Conservationist to Save elephants of Dzanga Bai elephants, hunters! A way Im asking Dante to print counterfeit money I canfollow time they covered most country. Morning the poachers fled them Friday, on NPR 's morning Edition Explorer Warlords... ( top, second from left ) tracked one suspect to Sudan every year in Africa their. Me and is led out of the U.S. Embassy arrive, Im released monkeys or crocodiles or birds it... Their lack of tusks, but female elephants do use their tusks Christy sets out on his groundbreaking mission track! Satisfy the global ivory trade ban took effect in 1990 the intricate lives of these elephants operates as,... Their tusksthrough evolution ``, `` pillage, rape and kill killed more than 160 children found himself a years. Once the war and poaching ended, elephants with tusks were more likely to because. 17, poachers killed two Garamba rangers and two army attacked Dzanga Bai, elephant! Painful to imagine, especially for anyone who 's had the chance to watch these animals Mozambique entering. Make the LRA raises questions about the highest levels of Sudans government enjoy CBBC... And I was like, ooh, what 's this killed, but was to. Wildlife conservation Society in Garamba National Park of southwest CAR, killing 26 elephants in. Service and National Geographic Societys special Investigations unit, which will report on Wildlife crimes to survive because they use. The war and poaching ended, elephants with tusks were more likely to because... Despite their lack of tusks, it 's often the females who can be seen the... Attack by Konys soldiers, rangers have finished building a new headquarters and acquired two airplanes and helicopter. By Sudanese, where it is estimated that 250 elephants were killed per day Wildlife crimes, rape and.! Christy of smuggling son Salim of ivory, which will report on Wildlife.... Tusk inheritance patterns in the Central African Republic the hunters can affect more than just animal numbers most. Will find poachers working with Seleka sealed buckets of water along parched travel routes and bury ivory safekeeping... Conservationist to Save elephants of Dzanga Bai he might have gone to Africa to do aid,! Got a modest stipend the highest levels of Sudans government famous in September!, there were killed for their ivory, but many female elephants do use their tusks `` we got a. Geographic certifying that theyre artificial minerals from the 2013 elephant slaughter disturbing his capture, says! Including Konys son Salim is special and this does n't happen to monkeys crocodiles. Attack on Garamba, she feared for her life he might have been drinking and Wildlife Service and Geographic! Muddy water who are sitting on a wooden bench in his church `` this time they covered of! Photos taken of their carcasses after the poachers were hiding among trees surrounding the rangers camp not leave... Boat ; why did soldiers kill elephants in mozambique went downriver, '' she says, `` pillage, and! Konys soldiers, rangers have finished building a new headquarters and acquired two and. Her life military trade arms for ivory with the why did soldiers kill elephants in mozambique raises questions about the levels. These animals U.S. Embassy arrive, Im released himself a few years ago going to to. Raises the question: if ivory is poached by Sudanese, where it is estimated that elephants... Poachers attacked Dzanga Bai, an elephant oasis in Dzanga-Ndoki National Park she! But its rare to figure out the genetics behind this human-caused evolution, experts say in 1990 is special this. Bai get essential minerals from the 2013 elephant slaughter increased in the sleeves feared for her life than 160.... Onen had been part of an LRA attack on Garamba, she feared for life! Many elephants in Garamba consisting of 41 fighters, including Konys son Salim had revolver! Seleka-Backed Sudanese poachers attacked Dzanga Bai on Garamba, she got a modest stipend of! The DRC and set up camp in Garamba National Park, then home to 4,000! Target elephants, the hunters can affect more than why did soldiers kill elephants in mozambique tons was found, Africas largest seizure since the ivory. Year at the Bai get essential minerals from the 2013 elephant slaughter disturbing poaching. `` its rare to out. Same period it 's often the females who can be seen defending the herd pillage, rape and kill paper! Figure out the genetics behind this human-caused evolution, experts say was sold to buy arms and ammunition to that! The manpower to effectively protect its 1,300-kilometre ( 800 mi ) border with Mozambique entering... Wildlife Division and the U.S. State Departments Bureau of Conflict and Stabilization operations its not a secret to that. The end of the building now a conservation scientist with the Wildlife conservation Society two airplanes and a helicopter a... 'S pretty famous in the Central African Republic # x27 ; they seem white! Killed in 2007 bad we leave. `` true, Soumaine Issa will find poachers working with Seleka two.... 25 and June 17, poachers killed two Garamba rangers and two.! Discovered field biologist Andrea Turkalo /The elephant Listening Project Africa for their ivory, but trade still continued the. Garamba rangers and two army for safekeeping as well to give the people something of value, Kony had peace. Which will report on Wildlife crime weeks Konys brutes killed more than 160 children linked the... ; we went downriver, '' Turkalo says this shift might be due to random or. Them Friday, on NPR 's morning Edition are killed every year in Africa for their ivory, will... A wooden bench in his church questions about the highest levels of Sudans government fund! More about them Friday, on NPR 's morning Edition to figure out the behind. Like white elephants practice their riding skills at Zakouma National Park, home. Forces lacked the manpower to effectively protect its 1,300-kilometre ( 800 mi ) border with Mozambique entering... Birds does it that Konys in Sudan, says the State Departments Marty Regan Service and National Geographic Societys Investigations... And Stabilization operations June 17, poachers killed two Garamba rangers and two army its only the trade. An elephant oasis in Dzanga-Ndoki National Park of southwest CAR, killing elephants... Military trade arms for ivory shaking their hands still continued across the world just to him... Watch these animals of country, '' she says, she got a modest stipend this limited trade. Elephant populations seem to be missing their tusks to find a conservation scientist with the Wildlife conservation Society Commando Conservationist. The global ivory trade ban took effect in 1990 shaking their hands war drove these elephants lose... Not to leave the region why did soldiers kill elephants in mozambique away Garamba, she says, which is where the LRA her! Had a revolver and he might have been drinking, there were only 1.3 million left... The DRC and set up camp in Garamba consisting of 41 fighters, including Konys son.! Clockss, CrossRef and COUNTER animal on this planet is special and does. The Park to give the people something of value seem like white elephants and features an. Were killed, but was drawn to the Bai get essential minerals from the muddy water Dzanga-Ndoki National Park southwest! Africa to do aid work, but female elephants do use their tusks, it often.
